The Pathetic State of Support Services for Men
In the recent past two articles on domestic violence against men have appeared in the national press, one in the Irish Examiner and one in the Irish Times.
That in the Examiner laid out the stark facts: Men’s Aid runs on a shoestring — two full-timers and four part-timers. In 2020 they did their best to respond to and support 5,500 men who contacted their domestic abuse service. This year it looks like it will be closer to 7,500.
Some of the men who call are sleeping in their cars at night or in a garden shed. A fairly common feature of the form of control exercised is false allegations against them by the person abusing them.
This piece by Fergus Finlay ended with the plea: We’ve simply got to talk about domestic violence, recognising that sometimes the roles of victim and perpetrator are reversed. We’ve got to fund the services decently.
The Irish Times article quoted Katrina Bentley CEO of Mens Aid: “During the last week of January and first week of February, within 10 days we had five very serious suicide situations at the end of the phone,” she said.
“We had to get Garda assistance for two of them, ring ahead to a hospital for a third and we talked the other two men down.”
Calls were missed because the helpline can deal with only two callers at a time
Ms Bentley said the organisation sought and was refused funding for a 24/7 helpline from the State’s child and family agency Tusla, which she criticises for allocating 1 per cent of its domestic, sexual and gender based violence (DSGBV) funding to the service.
It is one of just two Tusla-funded services dedicated to male victims.
Men’s Aid Ireland has €244,000 funding for its six staff operation (two full-timers and four part-timers) this year, an increase of €5,000 on last year.
There are no refuges for male victims and their children; there are more than 20 for women.
Services for Women
Compare this with the services for female victims. Safe Ireland says it acts on behalf of 39 frontline services around the country. It does not provide a helpline service itself but it employs 16 staff nonetheless and did have not one but two CEOs, Margaret McDermott and Sharon O’Halloran.
Here are the income figures for five leading organisations in 2018:
Safe Ireland: €1.274m total income in 2018 an 83% increase on 2017; funding by Tusla: €954,543 in 2018; €565,250 in 2017; increase of 69%; 16 staff.
Aoibhneas: €1.219m in 2018 a 14% increase on 2017; 27 staff; Assets 2018: €976,000
Adapt Domestic Abuse Services (Limerick); €2.064m in 2018 a 14% increase on 2017; 61 employees Assets 2018: €5.353m
Women’s Aid: €1.442m in 2018; 9% increase on 2017. Tusla €633,000, Pobal grant to support national organisations €80,000; CSVC (Dept of Justice Equality) €100,000; 23 staff
Sonas Housing Association €3.266m 30% increase on 2017; 40 staff; Assets 2018: €19.2m
Sonas owns properties in Killester, Clondalkin, Ballina, Navan, Ringsend, Ballymun, Blanchardstown, Stepaside, Belmayne, Tallaght and Wicklow. Received interest free housing loans. It operated 98 properties in 2018 and a crisis refuge in Blanchardstown. Sonas is also described as a Domestic Violence Charity CLG in its annual statement.
It received €2.1m from Tusla in 2018.
There is also a Women’s Aid Dundalk which received €1.004m in 2018 a 16% increase on 2017.
If we focus on Dublin alone There are four major organisations providing a helpline call centre and basic services for women: Women’s Aid, Aoibhneas, Sonas, Inchicore Outreach Centre and two refuges Rathmines and Saoirse Women’s Refuge.
There is no service for male victims in the Dublin Area where 1.5 million people reside.
Public Accounting, Review of public spending
At this point we need to ask some hard questions about what exactly is going on here.
The National Manager for Domestic, Sexual and Gender Based Violence Services with Tusla is Joan Mullan.
Joan Mullan has been in the role of National Manager for Domestic, Sexual and Gender Based Violence Services with Tusla, Child and Family Agency, since 2015. She leads the national programme which Tusla established to administer and support services for victims and survivors of domestic, sexual and gender based violence and which currently funds almost 60 specialist refuges, community based domestic violence services and rape crisis/sexual violence services throughout the country, including national helpline services.
Why has Joan Mullan never been required to account for her stewardship?
To our knowledge Mullan has never been asked to account in national media for the allocations made by Tusla. She has never been on national radio to answer questions about how Tusla makes decisions on funding, why so little is allocated to male support services, how much duplication is going on, how efficient the service is etc.
Has there ever been an audit carried out by the Comptroller and Auditor General of state funding to the DV sector?
(i) To determine need, how money is spent, how many staff are needed, how effective it is
(ii) To look at duplication of resources
With so many different groups/agencies involved in the sector there could be a real problem with transparency, competition for scarce resources and consequent duplication.
They are terrified of offending the women’s groups, NWC, Safe Ireland, Women’s Aid
To our knowledge no such audit has ever been carried out.
No political party in the state has taken up the challenge on this issue to ask the hard questions on the spending of public money, why the services for male victims is so tiny or to call for a review of spending.
The matter has never been taken up before the Public Accounts Committee where such an exercise could be carried out.
The truth is they are terrified of offending the women’s groups, NWC, Safe Ireland, Women’s Aid. Before the 2020 election in answer to a Question put by NWC, every party leader professed to be a feminist. The cowardice of politicians is simply craven.